Top Guitar Pick Holders for Every Guitarist


    This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Guitar & Music Institute may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

    Keeping your guitar picks organized and easily accessible is essential for any guitarist. A reliable guitar pick holder can make a significant difference in your playing experience.

    In this article, we’ll review some of the top guitar pick holders on the market, highlighting their unique features and benefits. Find the perfect pick holder to add to your collection.

    The Guitar Pick Holder Case is well named as it does exactly what it says on the tin! Ensuring that picks are always organized and readily accessible, it’s definitely one to consider if you’re in the market for such a product. This holder is not just practical but also reliable, making it a must-have for any guitarist. The design is user-friendly, allowing for quick and easy access to picks whenever needed.


    • Versatile storage solution not just for guitar picks but also for small music accessories and even mouth reed calls, showcasing its adaptability to various needs.
    • Compact and mobile design makes it easy to carry to guitar lessons or gigs, ensuring you always have your essentials organized and at hand.
    • Durable construction is frequently noted by users, implying the case can withstand regular use and transport without issues.
    • The internal storage compartments are smaller than some users expected, which could limit the amount of picks or accessories that can be stored.
    • Some users reported that picks can still end up being lost, suggesting the case might not completely solve the problem of pick misplacement for everyone.
    • There were issues with shipping for at least one customer, resulting in delayed receipt of the product, which could be a concern for those needing it by a specific date.

    As with many of these products, the generic case can be found in many different products, for a wide array of products such a camera gear etc. This doesn’t hold the case back though as its straightforward design is both effective and user-friendly, ensuring that your guitar picks are always safe and easily accessible. Whether you’re buying it for yourself or as a gift for a fellow musician, the Pick Holder Case is highly recommended.

    • The case is versatile, allowing you to organize picks of different thicknesses and also store small guitar accessories like a tuner or capo.
    • Priced fairly, offering good value for money for those looking for an affordable way to store and carry guitar picks and small accessories.
    • Highly rated by customers, with many finding it to be the perfect gift for guitar players, indicating satisfaction with its functionality and build quality.
    • The foam slots inside the case may not hold picks as securely as advertised, with some users reporting that picks can fall out or not stand up straight in the foam.
    • Some users found the case less visually appealing compared to other options, which might matter to those who prioritize aesthetics.
    • Limited capacity for picks, as some users wished it could fit more, making it less ideal for guitarists who need to carry a large collection of picks.

    Something a little more craft now. The Walnut Guitar Pick Storage Box is a functional accessory that any guitar player would appreciate if they are into wood. Its unique design not only adds a touch of elegance to your collection but also provides a practical solution for storing guitar picks. The high-quality material used in its construction ensures durability and longevity, making it a reliable choice for musicians. This storage box combines beauty and functionality seamlessly. Probably one for the older player perhaps?

    • It’s made from walnut, giving it a warm, natural aesthetic that not only looks good but also offers durability.
    • The box has a generous capacity, able to hold up to 20 picks depending on their thickness, making it very practical for guitarists who use picks of various sizes.
    • Its compact and easy-to-carry design makes it a perfect gift for musicians who are always on the go, ensuring they have their picks handy for any impromptu performance or practice session.
    • One review mentioned that the pick holder space might be too large for some, suggesting it might not be the best fit for those who prefer a snugger fit for their picks.
    • Since it’s a niche product tailored for guitarists, its appeal might be limited to those who actually play the guitar or appreciate guitar-related accessories.
    • The product is more of a sentimental gift than a practical one, as noted by a reviewer, which might not meet the expectations of those looking for a highly functional pick storage solution.

    Get stacks of picks and other guitar accessories in this pick holder case. For some, the fact that it looks like a guitar body will be great; for others, naff. Make your choice and take your pick (pun intended).

    • The case boasts a sturdy construction, capable of withstanding rough handling, including being chewed on by pets, which ensures your picks are well-protected.
    • It offers ample storage space, accommodating over 63 picks of all sizes, which is perfect for musicians who own a vast collection of plectrums.
    • Designed for convenience, the case is praised for its capacity to organize picks neatly, making it easier for users to find and display their collection without digging through a pile.
    • The case is larger than an average adult hand, which might not appeal to those seeking a compact storage solution for their picks.
    • While it’s mainly a pick holder, those looking for additional compartments for strings or tuners might find the storage options limited.
    • Some users might find the price point of $14.99 a bit steep, especially if they are looking for a simple solution for pick storage.

    In this age where smoking is now thought of as only slightly better than being related to Adolf Hitler, this is a guitar pick holder on the edge! It’s probably not the kind of thing a cool dude would buy, so why make this holder in the shape of a lighter?

    • The guitar pick holder is handmade from natural wood, offering a unique and high-quality appearance that varies from piece to piece.
    • It has a strong magnet lock to securely hold the guitar picks inside, ensuring they are safe and protected.
    • Compact and easy to carry, this pick holder fits easily into any bag and can hold a sufficient number of picks (5-18), making it very convenient for guitar players.
    • Some users found the product overpriced for its quality, indicating that it may not hold up well over time.
    • The included guitar pick was criticized for being too thick, making it more of a decorative piece rather than a practical pick for playing.
    • The design might not be as noticeable without direct light, and some units might arrive with small scratches, suggesting inconsistency in finish quality.

    One for the older gentleman in your life perhaps? Looking like the kind of wooden item that would hold snuff, this has a vintage look about it. As a gift it might even work.

    • Comes with a high-quality, well-made black walnut wood holder that not only looks great but also provides a secure place to store your picks.
    • The set includes 1 wooden pick and 6 celluloid picks in 3 different thicknesses, offering versatility for different playing styles and preferences.
    • Features a strong magnet for easy opening and secure closing, ensuring your picks stay safely inside and are easily accessible.
    • The product image may show the front print as more saturated than it appears in person, which could be slightly disappointing for those expecting a vivid design.
    • With only 4 reviews, the product has limited feedback, making it harder to gauge long-term durability and satisfaction from a wider range of customers.
    • The included picks are on the harder end, which might not suit players who prefer softer picks for their music style.

    A Pick holder that looks like a pick, who would have thunk it? Again, this is one of those ideas that is either great or absolutely dull depending on your cynic rating.

    • Holds a large number of picks and other small guitar accessories, making it great for musicians who travel.
    • Durable and sturdy case design ensures your picks and accessories are protected.
    • Includes a mesh pocket for additional storage, offering extra room for things like capos, strings, and peg winders.
    • Picks can slide out of their pockets when the case is closed, posing a risk of them spilling out upon opening.
    • The case is specifically designed for picks and small accessories, so it might not hold larger items comfortably.
    • Lacks a locking mechanism, which might concern those looking for secure storage options.

    Looks good and holds more than picks, so worth a closer inspection. With all of these items though, realise, they are much smaller than they look.

    • The case offers ample space, capable of organizing over 57 picks, ensuring all your picks are in one place.
    • Its durable ‘rubber-ish’ outer shell combined with a fabric and clear plastic interior provides a balance between protection and visibility of contents.
    • Includes a zippered mesh pocket on the side, adding versatility for storing strings or other small guitar accessories.
    • The case is described as larger than necessary by some, which might not fit well into guitar cases or add unnecessary bulk to gig bags.
    • While it holds a significant number of picks, one reviewer found it less useful, suggesting it holds less than expected for its size.
    • Its specific design and size might not meet every guitarist’s needs or preferences for portability and storage efficiency.

    Nice quality to it and it looks like a pick. Please see previous review above for thoughts on this idea.

    • The XTON Guitar Picks Holder is highly durable and reliable, perfect for musicians on the go.
    • It offers a stylish way to store and organize guitar picks, making it not only a practical choice but also a fashionable accessory.
    • Compact and portable, it can hold a decent amount of picks, ensuring you always have your picks within easy reach.
    • Some users might find the design not aligning with their personal style preferences.
    • Limited to storing picks only, it might not be the best choice for those looking for a more versatile storage solution.
    • Though durable, the case’s material may not appeal to everyone, especially those preferring natural over synthetic materials.

    It looks like this could be used to hold your shaving kit (remember them?) and to be fair, it probably could take a disposable razor or two.

    • The pick holder is versatile, compatible with all sizes of picks, making it a universal storage solution for guitarists.
    • It has a durable exterior, ensuring that your picks are well-protected against everyday wear and tear.
    • The case offers ample storage space, with multiple slots for picks and even some extra room for strings and other small guitar accessories.
    • Some users reported an odd smell upon initial use, which could be off-putting for sensitive noses.
    • Despite its overall sturdy build, there were remarks about the case feeling somewhat cheap, possibly in the zipper quality or the internal materials used.
    • The case’s larger capacity might make it bulkier than expected, potentially making it less convenient for those who prefer minimalistic or lighter carry options.

    This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Guitar & Music Institute may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.